17A Cafe

Amazing food and coffee. Owner is a real sweetheart and has great stories to tell.

This is an absolute gem of a cafe. Scott is super nice and makes incredible homemade food. I will be back! Thanks Scott for making me the Schwarma, an off menu item!

I used to live in Roslyn but now live in London! I travel all the way from across the pond just for Scotty’s bagels. Best bagels ever!

Went there for a coffee and muffin but was pleasantly welcomed by Scotty Bagel the owner. The place is tiny but packed with goodies. I asked Scotty to make me a nice breakfast and he proceeded to making a sampler of 4 of his smoked salmons on a scooped out everything bagel cut in four quarters with scallion cream cheese, tomatoes, onions and squeezed lime. OUT OF THIS WORLD. To my delight he also has flavored creamers for my coffee. And he made everything with care and LOVE. Great experience. As I was leaving he said if I call my order beforehand he’ll have it ready for pickup so I wouldn’t have to wait next time. This is one place I would 100% trust to make my order to perfection.

My Cuz and I were headed back to the Hamptons from the city and were looking for a great breakfast/coffee/bagel place with vegan options! We stumbled across 17A Café with a Google search and it did not disappoint! I got the vegan bacon, egg & cheese sandwich on a sesame bagel, and I can honestly say that it was the best I’ve had! The coffee was also a hit! My cousin got the toasted almond iced coffee and I got a cold brew. Both were delectable! Aside from this being a hidden gem, the owner Scotty was incredibly friendly and hospitable to speak with in the cute little ambience of a quaint little neighborhood café. He made many recommendations and it was a pleasure discussing a lot of the plant-based options he carries. I didn’t leave there empty-handed and brought home a specially made vegan salmon patty on a bialy. Omnivores and herbivores alike, it’s worth the trip! Next time we are in the area, we will definitely be returning!

Great spot! Food is always fresh and delicious! Scott also has the best lox around, hands down! My go-to spot for chicken salad, tuna salad, and iced coffee. If you are in the area and need are looking for a bite, this is the place to go!

Great little cafe! Scott, the owner is the nicest guy. We had a lovely chat this morning. Like me, he’s one of these old school guys who worked hard from a young age, has a really strong work ethic, and is just a nice fella. Definitely try to support this small business. He made me an everything bagel with tofu scallion cream cheese and freshly squeezed blood orange juice. Vegan friendly.

This isn’t just a deli. It’s a gourmet culinary experience disguised as a cozy local spot. Every bite here tells you that Scott, the owner (who also works the counter), genuinely cares about quality. He hand-selects the freshest ingredients daily, and it shows in everything from the vibrant flavors to the thoughtful plating. The menu is creative and surprisingly diverse, with vegan options that are just as mouthwatering as the classics. Whether you’re grabbing a cold brew with one of their specialty milks or diving into a handcrafted sandwich, you’ll be shocked that food this good is tucked away in such an unassuming spot. Scott brings an energy and warmth that makes you feel like a welcome regular, even on your first visit. This is one of those rare places where the passion for food and people truly shines. Cozy, charming, and absolutely delicious — 17A Cafe deserves every one of its five stars and more.